The Secular Humanists of the Lowcountry

Join / Donate

All Forums > News and Current Events >

News and Current Events

Feb 23 2005
Atheist Family: Keep Boy Scout Recruits Out of Schools

Atheist asks state Supreme Court to review Boy Scout ruling

LANSING, Mich. An atheist family is appealing a Michigan court ruling that found nothing wrong about a school district letting the Boy Scouts recruit inside schools.

An attorney for a father and son says they're asking the Michigan Supreme Court to consider an appeal in a religious discrimination case involving the Mount Pleasant Public Schools.

The school district allowed the Boy Scouts to hang posters and have a recruiter invite students to an informational meeting.

The state appeals court ruled last month that the policy's purpose was secular and did NOT advance religion over non-religion.

The family argues that the Boy Scouts discriminates against nonreligious people by denying them membership if they don't swear to religious oaths.

Feb 24 2005

Back in the Sixties, I was given the choice of a tambourine or a Boy Scout uniform. Fortunately, I chose the tambourine.

Mar 3 2005
Related Story

Here is a related story, this time in Oregon.

Court of Appeals backs atheist mother in Boy Scouts case


Associated Press Writer

SALEM, Ore. - The state Court of Appeals ruled Wednesday there is "substantial evidence" that the Portland School District illegally discriminated against an atheist student by allowing in-school recruiting by the Boy Scouts.

The 6-3 decision is the latest development in a long-running battle by an atheist mother to prevent the Boy Scouts from recruiting in Portland schools because the organization requires a belief in God.

The new ruling sends the case back to the state school superintendent for conciliation efforts to resolve the dispute. The district, meanwhile, is considering adopting a policy that could ban Scouts from recruiting during school hours.

The controversy began in 1996, when Nancy Powell, an atheist, objected to Boy Scout recruiting visits to an elementary school attended by her son, Remington, who is now in high school.

Nancy Powell sued the school district in 1998, claiming that because the Scout oath and principles require a belief in God, the recruiting violated the Oregon Constitution's ban on government involvement with religion.

The appeals court in 2002 ruled in the school district's favor, saying the recruiting did not amount to an "unconstitutionally excessive entanglement of government with religion."

The state Supreme Court let the lower court decision stand by refusing to review it.

The Court of Appeals' decision Wednesday came in a separate lawsuit brought by Powell under a state statute forbidding public schools from discriminating based on religion.

Former State School Superintendent Stan Bunn concluded that there was no solid evidence of discrimination, but the appeals court disagreed in a ruling upholding Multnomah County Circuit Judge Ellen Rosenblum.

"There is substantial evidence that, by giving the Scouts the access that it does, the district treats those students who are eligible to join the Scouts differently from those who are not," the appeals court said.

The court said while all students have been required to listen to an introductory presentation, "only the students who meet a religious test may accept the invitation to join."

That amounts to substantial evidence, the court said, that the district "subjects persons to differentiated treatment in a school activity on the ground of religion."

(Copyright 2005 by The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved.)

Return to News and Current Events Forum
Return to Discussion Home

Webmaster: Alex Kasman 2016